Medical Billing Audit Checklist: What to Gather Before a Review
A medical billing audit starts before anyone examines the first claim. If the records are incomplete or the question is too broad, time goes into reconstructing the story instead of understanding the problem.
This medical billing audit checklist helps a practice prepare for a focused review. The exact information needed depends on the engagement. Agree on that scope first, then gather the records through an appropriate secure process.
1. State the question and the limits
Write down the concern in one or two sentences. For example: “We want to understand why these services are repeatedly denied by this payer.” That is more useful than “Our billing is a mess.”
Identify the period under review, providers or services included, and how encounters will be selected. Record exclusions as well. A sample of recurring denials should not be treated as a representative picture of all billing without a suitable sampling approach.
2. Match claims to supporting records
For the agreed encounters, assemble the submitted claim information and the clinical documentation that supports it. Keep encounter identifiers consistent so the reviewer can connect the service date, codes, provider, and record.
Include relevant versions or correction history when a claim has been changed. The reviewer needs to know what was actually submitted and what the record said at the relevant time. Do not rewrite a record to make it appear that information was present earlier; address documentation questions through the practice’s proper process.
3. Gather payer responses and follow-up
Collect the relevant remittance information, denial explanations, records requests, and correspondence. Include dates and reference numbers from calls or other follow-up if available.
A denial label alone may not explain the cause. The sequence matters: initial submission, payer response, correction or appeal, and later action. Identify deadlines in the actual payer communication rather than relying on a general internet checklist.
4. Bring the rules that apply
Identify the payer and program involved and locate the policies, agreements, and coding references relevant to the review period. Medicare rules are not a substitute for checking a commercial payer’s requirements.
CMS’s National Correct Coding Initiative resources can inform a Medicare coding review, including certain code combinations and units. They are one part of the review and should be used with the applicable documentation and other requirements.
5. Explain how work moves through the practice
Describe who enters information, selects or checks codes, submits claims, posts responses, and follows up. Note which tasks happen in different systems and how an unresolved item reaches the next person.
Gather the reports needed for the agreed question, such as denial or aging reports. Confirm what each report includes before comparing totals. Differences in dates, claim status, or adjustments can make two reports look inconsistent even when they are measuring different things.
6. Agree on security and deliverables
Settle access, record transfer, and appropriate confidentiality arrangements before sharing patient information. Keep protected health information out of the public inquiry form.
Agree on what the reviewer will return: the findings, supporting evidence, unresolved questions, recommendations, and limits of the review. Ask how confirmed issues will be distinguished from items that need additional records or payer clarification.
7. Plan the next action
Assign responsibility for considering the findings and documenting the response. A useful review may lead to staff education, a process change, a more focused investigation, or advice from another qualified professional.
HHS-OIG’s physician compliance guidance connects monitoring and auditing with education and corrective action. Treat the report as part of that continuing work. A review does not guarantee payment or mean every identified issue has the same remedy.
Prepare a review that answers your question
I’m Bambie Cleveland, a medical billing and audit consultant in Joplin. I help practices examine billing, coding, documentation, and insurance audit questions. Contact me with a brief description of the concern so we can discuss the scope and what to gather.
Comments