E/M compliance case study: what a 200-claim review revealed
Home › Case Studies › E/M compliance case study: what a 200-claim review revealed
A review of evaluation and management (E/M) claims found frequent coding inaccuracies. Practice and provider details are omitted to protect identity.
What the sample showed
Over the course of a year, 200 claims were audited. The review notes recorded a 14% accuracy rate, meaning 86% of the sampled claims were billed incorrectly. These were the reviewed claims, not the provider’s complete claim population.
Why the finding matters
The review identified a substantial accuracy concern within the sample. Similar errors could continue if coding and documentation practices were not corrected. The full scope cannot be inferred from the 200 claims alone.
Validate the numbers before reporting an overpayment
The review notes contain an aggregate overpayment figure that does not reconcile with the recorded claim count and per-claim difference. I have not presented that aggregate as a confirmed overpayment.
A defensible follow-up would compare each claim with its documentation and applicable coding guidance, confirm which claims were actually overpaid, calculate the amount from claim-level paid values, and document the corrective steps and any required payer response.
What this case does—and does not—establish
The source notes do not say whether those follow-up actions were completed. This case therefore does not claim a final repayment or enforcement outcome. A high error rate is a reason to investigate carefully; it does not by itself establish fraud or intent.
Comments